The Simchah of Giving by Rabbi Yitzy Kopstick ‘(18)

5787/2026

After Yaakov Avinu sneaks out of Lavan's house with his family, Lavan chases him down. When he catches up to them, he begins with a surprising statement:

“Lamah Nachbeita Levroach VaTignov Oti VeLo Higadita Li VaAshaleichacha BeSimchah U’VeShirim BeTof UVeChinor”, “Why did you flee in secrecy and mislead me and not tell me? I would have sent you off with festive music, with tambourines and harps.” (BeReishit 31:27) 

Now, thinking about it for a moment, is this really the reaction that Lavan would have had? Yaakov Avinu had been living with him for the past twenty years, and now he was leaving for good with his wives and children. You would have expected him to protest his leaving. And yet, Lavan says that he would have sent him off with a huge celebration!

Rav Shmuel Botnick presents the following approach: Rav Tzadok HaKohen writes that the initial usage of a word or concept in the Torah reveals something about that word’s essence. Interestingly, this is the very first time the word Simchah appears. What is it about this rant that reveals the defining theme of Simchah?

Lavan was a rotten character, no doubt about that. But there happens to be one praiseworthy act that the Torah reveals about him. In Parashat Chayei Sarah, when Eliezer arrives in Charan to find a wife for Yitzchak, Lavan says to him:

“Lamah Ta’amod BaChutz VaAnochi Piniti HaBayit U’Makom LaGemalim”, “Why are you standing outside? I have cleaned out the house and made room for the camels.” (BeReishit 24:31)

Rashi explains that the “cleaning of the house” refers to Avodah Zarah. Meaning, Lavan removed all of the Avodah Zarah from his home to accommodate Eliezer. Now, we know how much Lavan loved his Avodah Zarah. When those same idols were taken from him upon Yaakov’s escape, he was furious, turning the tents of Rachel, Leah, Bilhah, and Zilpah upside down in search of them. Yet, to make Eliezer comfortable, he removed these very idols from his home. He fulfilled the mitzvah of Hachnasat Orchim even though it was very difficult for him. And maybe, at that moment, Lavan experienced the simcha of Hachnasat Orchim, the feeling of joy when giving to others.

So yes, Lavan didn't want Yaakov to leave, and yes, he was certainly a wicked person. But Lavan knew that Yaakov wasn’t going to remain in his house forever. Rav Botnick suggested that maybe the Simchah that Lavan had experienced when welcoming Eliezer into his home was a feeling that he wanted to experience again, and he was waiting for Yaakov to send him off in style. Perhaps this is why Lavan was so upset with Yaakov - he would no longer have the opportunity to experience that feeling.

Therefore, this story of Lavan, and the first time the word Simchah appears in the Torah, teaches us something fundamental about the true meaning of happiness. True Simchah comes from the opportunity to give to someone else, even when it means stepping outside our comfort zone. In our own lives, we are constantly presented with opportunities to go out of our way for others. The more we learn to recognize those opportunities and take advantage of them, the truer Simchah we can bring into our own lives.

When Love Transcends Logic by Dovid Ratzersdorfeer (‘27)